The "Edit Page Properties" button was not filling with the proper "Edit Page Properties" information. I tracked the problem down to the extension "Gobernalia BE Drag and Drop." Will have to be aware of the status of the function override getTable_tt_content -> option_showBigButtons -> line 560 when this extension is upgraded next.
File modified: typo3conf/ext/gb_bedraganddrop/class.ux_tx_cms_layout.php
Plan: Submit a patch back to the TER (http://typo3.org/extensions).