Title

Cankerworms in North Dakota

(E999, Revised March 2020)
File
Publication File:
Summary

Cankerworms appear in small numbers every year, feeding on tree leaves and buds. Cankerworm outbreaks can cause severe damage, so knowing their tree hosts, the life cycle of fall and spring cankerworms and pest management can help detect and manage them.

Lead Author
Lead Author:
Janet Knodel, NDSU Extension Entomologist
Other Authors

Lezlee Johnson, Forestry and Fire Management Team Leader, North Dakota Forest Service; James Walker, Assistant Curator, University of Minnesota; Joe Zeleznik, NDSU Extension Forester

Availability
Availability:
Available in print from the NDSU Distribution Center.

Contact your county NDSU Extension office to request a printed copy.
NDSU staff can order copies online (login required).

Publication Sections

Table of Contents

Cankerworms (Lepidoptera, Geometridae) are small caterpillars that feed on tree leaves and buds each spring. These caterpillars move in a looping inch-wormlike manner and have chewing mouthparts that cause defoliation in the tree canopy.

Cankerworms appear every year in small numbers and usually go unnoticed. Every few years, however, cankerworm outbreaks defoliate large numbers of landscape and forest trees severely.

Many years can pass between large outbreaks, and each outbreak can last three or more years. Severe defoliation by cankerworms needs to be managed to maintain maximum tree vigor.

Tree Hosts

Several tree species are infested by cankerworms, including elm, hackberry and apple, which are the most vulnerable. Defoliation also may occur on basswood, oak, boxelder, maple and ash. While defoliation in a single season may not damage a large, mature, vigorous tree, defoliation for several consecutive seasons weakens trees (especially young trees) and makes them more susceptible to drought, herbicide drift and other pests.

Life Cycle of Cankerworms

Two species of cankerworms can be found in North Dakota: spring cankerworm and fall cankerworm. Caterpillars (larvae) of the two species look similar to each other and feed on tree foliage at the same time in early spring. In fact, spring and fall cankerworms can be found feeding on the same tree. However, their egg-laying habits and life cycles differ. Both species have one generation per year.

Fall Cankerworm — Alsophila pometaria (Harris)

■ Identification

Adult moth:

• Male cankerworm moths are about 1 inch long and brownish gray, and have two light, irregular bands on their forewings (Figure 1). 

• The wingless females are also brownish gray and approximately ¾ inch long (Figure 2).

Caterpillar (larva) (Figure 3):

• Caterpillar size varies from less than 1/16 of an inch long (young) to 1 inch long (mature).

• They are light green to brownish green, with white lines running along the sides and a dark band down the back.

• Each caterpillar has three pairs of fleshy legs called prolegs (Figure 4) on the back half of the body; one of the pairs is relatively small and rudimentary.

■ Life Cycle (Figure 5)

The fall cankerworm overwinters as an egg (Figure 6). Eggs hatch from April through May, usually when elm buds open. Newly hatched caterpillars readily feed on newly formed leaves. Feeding continues through June into early July.

Caterpillars are about 1 inch long when fully grown and complete their development in approximately four weeks. Mature caterpillars drop from their tree host in early July and construct silk pupal cocoons in the soil (Figure 7).

Adults emerge from cocoons from late September through October. Adults mate and the wingless females climb up the trunks of trees, where they lay compact egg masses high up on the trunk and branches (Figure 6). The male and female cankerworms die after egg laying.

Fall Cankerworm
Photo Credit:
L. Johnson, ND Forest Service
Fall cankerworm
Figure 1
Photo Credit:
G. Fauske, NDSU
Figure 1. Male fall cankerworm moth
Figure 2
Photo Credit:
G. Fauske, NDSU
Wingless female fall cankerworm moth with egg mass
Figure 3
Photo Credit:
J. Zeleznik, NDSU
Fall cankerworm (caterpillar)
Figure 4
Fleshy prolegs of spring cankerworm (2 prolegs, top) and fall cankerworm (3 prolegs, bottom)
Figure 6
Photo Credit:
J. Zeleznik, NDSU
Close up of fall cankerworm egg mass
Figure 7
Photo Credit:
W.M. Ciesla, Forest Health Management International, Bugwood.org
Pupae of fall cankerworm in soil
Figure 11
Life cycle of spring cankerworm

Spring Cankerworm — Paleacrita vernata (Peck)

■ Identification

Adult moth:

• Males are brownish gray, with three dark bands visible on the forewings (Figure 8).

• Females are wingless and brown to black, with a dark stripe down the middle of the back (Figure 9).

Caterpillar (larvae) (Figure 10):

• Caterpillars of spring cankerworms are similar to fall cankerworms in size.

• Caterpillars vary from green to reddish brown or black, with faint dark lines or a yellow stripe on the sides.

• Spring cankerworms have only two pairs of abdominal prolegs (Figure 4).

■ Life Cycle (Figure 11):

The spring cankerworm passes the winter as a mature larva in the soil. It pupates in late winter and cankerworm moths emerge in early spring, typically during the last week of March in North Dakota, or as soon as the ground thaws.

The wingless females mate and climb up the trees, where they deposit their eggs in loose clusters under bark in crevices and other protected places on the trunk and lower branches (Figure 12). Eggs hatch in early May and larvae begin feeding on the new foliage. Caterpillars complete feeding in mid-June through early July and descend to the ground on silken strands, where they pupate in the soil and remain dormant until the following spring.

Both species of cankerworm often will spin down from the tree on silk threads when disturbed. These threads also serve as a means of transport by wind, and small caterpillars may be blown a considerable distance where they infest new trees.

Figure 1
Photo Credit:
G. Fauske, NDSU
Figure 1. Male fall cankerworm moth
Figure 9
Photo Credit:
J. Kalisch, University of Nebraska
Female spring cankerworm moth
Figure 10a
Photo Credit:
J. Kalisch, University of Nebraska
Light form of spring cankerworms
Figure 10b
Photo Credit:
J. Kalisch, University of Nebraska
Dark form of spring cankerworms
Figure 5
Life cycle of fall cankerworm

Tree Damage

As leaves begin to emerge in the spring, the tiny caterpillars begin to feed on the foliage. The first sign of larval feeding is
the appearance of tiny holes known as “shot holes” between
the leaf veins (Figure 13).

Shot hole damage becomes apparent when caterpillars are ¼ to ½ inch long and will occur as early as mid-May in North Dakota. As the caterpillars grow, they continue to feed on the leaf tissue, skeletonizing the tissue between leaf veins, and eventually the entire leaf is consumed, leaving only the midrib (Figure 14).

Repeated defoliation for three or more consecutive years will kill many of the upper branches and decrease the tree’s aesthetic value. Severe defoliation also causes trees to be more susceptible to other stresses, such as drought, diseases, other insects and competition from other trees, especially in overcrowded shelterbelts.

Figure 12
Photo Credit:
J. Kalisch, University of Nebraska
Spring cankerworm egg mass
Figure 13
Photo Credit:
J. Zeleznik, NDSU
'shot hole' defoliation caused by cankerworm feeding
Figure 14
Photo Credit:
USDA Forest Service, Ogden, Bugwood.org
Severe defoliation caused by cankerworm feeding
Figure 15
Photo Credit:
W.A. Carothers, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org
Trunk banding for detection of cankerworms
Figure 16
Photo Credit:
J.A. Capony, Virginia Department of Forestry, Bugwood.org
Parasitized fall cankerworm
Figure 17
Photo Credit:
J. Knodel, NDSU
Virus-infected thistle caterpillar

Pest Management

■ Monitoring

Early detection of cankerworms and defoliation is important. Monitor the upper tree branches for young caterpillars and
early defoliation using binoculars during the spring from early
to late May.

Early larval feeding injury often is overlooked until large holes are present in leaves and caterpillars are mature. Insecticide treatments usually are not warranted this late because extensive defoliation already has occurred and mature caterpillars will be dropping to pupate in the soil.

■ Trunk Banding

Tree banding is not an effective control of cankerworms, although it can be used for early detection. For early cankerworm detection, place a 3- to 4-inch band of a sticky adhesive compound completely around the trunk about 5 feet above the ground (Figure 15). Because female moths are wingless and must crawl up the trunk of their host tree to lay eggs, this band traps females and prevents them from
depositing eggs on the upper trunk and branches.

Tree banding should be done during early to mid-September to trap fall cankerworms and again in mid-March to trap spring cankerworm females. The canopies of treated trees should be isolated from the canopies of neighboring trees. If the canopies of several trees intermingle, the trunks of all of the trees must
be banded.

When banding is used as an early detection technique in shelterbelts, the adhesive should be applied as soon as the snow melts. The bands should be placed selectively on three or four trees along the length of the shelterbelt and monitored weekly for the presence of trapped moths. If large numbers are present, serious defoliation is likely to occur and management may be warranted when cankerworm larvae begin feeding.

Adhesive compounds are available as a paste and also as a pressurized aerosol spray. Because the paste can be applied easily with a putty knife, it is often the best formulation to use
for the first application of a new band.

Old bands may be rejuvenated easily by spraying with the aerosol formulation. Adhesive compounds are generally nontoxic and present no potential hazards to the applicator
or environment.

■ Biological Control

Several species of parasitic wasps are known to attack eggs or caterpillars of fall and spring cankerworms (Figure 16). However, the parasitism rate is typically too low (about 15% to 20%) for effective management. A nuclear polyhedrosis virus also can infect and kill caterpillars (Figure 17), especially during outbreak years and moist conditions.

■ Chemical Control

Insecticidal control measures are most effective if implemented when the caterpillars are young (about ½ inch long) and feeding defoliation is low. Spray timing is critical and, if done at the correct time, only a single application will be needed.

Insecticides can be applied by ground-based equipment or by aerial equipment and should be directed at the trunk, branches and newly expanding leaves. Aerial application is fast and convenient and most often is used to apply insecticides in shelterbelts.

Ground-based equipment has been shown to be effective and may give better vertical coverage of foliage in the tree canopy. Good coverage of the infested trees is critical for acceptable control.

While timely insecticide treatments directed at the early larval stage of cankerworm provides effective control, many trees in residential areas are too large to treat thoroughly with spray equipment available to the average homeowner. Also, the homeowner often is unaware a cankerworm infestation exists until after extensive damage already has occurred to the tree. Insecticides listed for management of cankerworms includes biopesticides and conventional insecticides.

Biorational pesticides (Table 1) are natural pesticides from natural materials, such as minerals, bacteria, plants or animals or insect growth regulators.

Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki (Btk) is a selective bacterial pathogen that kills the caterpillars of cankerworms as well as caterpillars of other moths and butterflies. These bacteria do not have a detrimental effect on beneficial insects, wildlife or humans.

Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki is highly recommended for management of cankerworms where possible. For optimal control, apply Btk when caterpillars are less than ½ inch long, about 10 days after egg hatch.

Synthetic insecticides (Table 2) are recommended when caterpillars are greater than ½ inch long and extensive defoliation already has occurred.

“Always read, understand and follow the pesticide label. The label is the law.”

Table 1. Biorational pesticide products for cankerworm control.

Active IngredientCommercial Trade Name
azadirachtinAzatin XL, Bioneem
Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstakiDiPel, Javelin, Lepinox
diflubenzuronDimilin (insect growth regulator)
insecticidal soapSafer Insecticidal Soap
pyrethrinsPyGanic
spinosadConserve, Entrust, SpinTor
tebufenozideMimic (insect growth regulator)

Table 2. Synthetic insecticide products for cankerworm control.

Active IngredientCommercial Trade Name
acephateOrthene, Isotox
bifenthrinBifenthrinPro, Talstar
carbarylSevin
cyfluthrinTempo
deltamethrinDeltaGard
lambda-cyhalothrinScimitar
malathionMalathion
permethrinAstro

Disclaimer: Mention of any product does not imply an endorsement of one product versus another nor discrimination against any product not mentioned by NDSU Extension or the authors.

This publication originally was authored by R. Dean Christie, former NDSU Extension entomologist, 1990.

Partial funding for this publication is made available through support from the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Forest Service State and Private Forestry Program.

E999 (Revised March 2020)

North Dakota State University

NDSU Extension does not endorse commercial products or companies even though reference may be made to tradenames, trademarks or service names. NDSU encourages you to use and share this content, but please do so under the conditions of our Creative Commons license. You may copy, distribute, transmit and adapt this work as long as you give full attribution, don’t use the work for commercial purposes and share your resulting work similarly. For more information, visit www.ag.ndsu.edu/agcomm/creative-commons.

For more information on this and other topics, see www.ndsu.edu/extension

County commissions, North Dakota State University and U.S. Department of Agriculture cooperating. NDSU does not discriminate in its programs and activities on the basis of age, color, gender expression/identity, genetic information, marital status, national origin, participation in lawful off-campus activity, physical or mental disability, pregnancy, public assistance status, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, spousal relationship to current employee, or veteran status, as applicable. Direct inquiries to Vice Provost for Title IX/ADA Coordinator, Old Main 201, NDSU Main Campus, 701-231-7708, ndsu.eoaa@ndsu.edu. This publication will be made available in alternative formats for people with disabilities upon request, 701-231-7881. 3M-3-20